Jenny Case Summarized for Republicans

[Mary]

This first post is a placeholder. It will eventually be replaced with our summary case and devil's advocate points about Jenny should she be our nominee.

Please post your arguments and counterarguments below and over the course of the day we can come up with a concise brief for the Republicans to read in the short time they have for their final votes at Exile tonight.

[Awohali]

1. She role claimed for Allan in an odd situation.
A. She claimed his role an hour before the votes were due.
B. She did not verify the vote count herself, but rather took Savannah's word for it. Savannah is dead. The vote count was already towards Savannah being voted out.
C. She cited the unknown votes as being what made it important to claim early, but 3/5 of the unknown votes were herself, Allan, and Nita, who was the other person that knew of Allan's role.

2. She does not look for spies.
In her own admission, she looks for people who are Citizens to narrow down the list. While I see nothing wrong with noting when someone is perceived as a Citizen, I do see a great deal of things wrong with not hunting for Spies. In a game this large, she will not have a narrowed down list for several more episodes.
What is she doing in the mean time?

[Jenny]

C. She cited the unknown votes as being what made it important to claim early, but 3/5 of the unknown votes were herself, Allan, and Nita, who was the other person that knew of Allan's role.

Wanted to clarify something on this one, I wasn't talking about people that hadn't stated their votes yet, I was talking about possible vote changes that nobody knew about, or could see was happening, like when Al voted for Owen during the first exile.

[Cory]

3. She voted against the Alexei wagon. Her stated reason is that she preferred to allow Alexei survive a few days longer, fearing that he would be another "Callahan from Spies 6," due to his outburst in the group chat.

[Mary]

devil's advocate: Allan is still alive even though Jenny first knew he had a role. Unless they're Spies together, that's a point in her favor. Counterpoint: risky for Jenny to kill him once Nita knew, unless Nita and Jenny are Spies together.

She seemed reluctant to discuss Alexei and seemed to disappear in group chats when Alexei was mentioned or around.

Says to Alexei: "It sounds like you got some 'splainin to do" but never asks him a question and doesn't suspect him. Looks like fence-riding.

She ignored a couple of times Tina brought up direct contradictions between Jenny-Alexei conversations and ones Tina saw.

Locked on to early Zed suspicions for what look like pretty weak reasons.

Jenny posts logs but doesn't seem to read them.