Ep 7: Exile

[Broderick]

This is where those in the Senate post who they are voting for.
You would think it common sense, considering those in the HoR do it. Apparently - not.

Get to it.

[Lawrence]

I too believe that the Senate should have to post who they are voting for, and why. It seems easier for any criminals among the Senate will have an easier job manipulating if their voting is not made in public.

[Jasmine]

I recommend voting for: Claude.

I'll be online throughout tonight, would love to talk to everyone and hear who they are thinking of exiling!!

[Awohali]

I will likely vote Jenny if I am able to gather support for her. I shall summarize my reasons here:

1. She has a horrendous voting record.
2. She does not Spy Hunt.
3. She knew Nita was a 3rd party player looking to work with the Spies and did not reveal that information until much later when Nita died.
4. She has given terrible and sometimes unexplained reasons for voting or suspecting someone. My favorite is that she suspected Kiara because she "had been wondering where she was". Jenny literally did not provide any more reason than that in two days of questioning. She has also not yet explained her nomination of me this episode.
5. This is not a concrete point, but Jenny is very evasive when questioned, and will often give long answers that dance around the actual question and say as little as possible. This is my own interpretation and I do not wish to force it upon anyone else, but I still feel it necessary to state.

[Cinnamyn]

awohali, 4 reazinz in my thred.

[Chance]

Jul 25, 2010 21:36:38 GMT -6 Cinnamyn said:

awohali, 4 reazinz in my thred.

same here.

[Hambone]

JENNY!!!!!! For many many many many reasons.

[Jasmine]

What are the Jenny reasons? Suddenly many people are jumping on this, and I still don't really get it? Is it the same reasons as Awohali has for her...?

[Hambone]

The reasons I've been giving all game. Yes, to Awohali's but, more... Here are my main ones (or the ones I can get off the top of my head at least)

1.) Revealing Allan's role when Savannah had more votes and was the one getting exiled
2.) Not revealing Nita's third party role
3.) Openly admitting that she searches for Cits and not Spies
4.) Never making a case... all game. As stated above, she has suspected people just because they're not online much.
5.) Suspecting and going after Z practically all game. I believe she used him as a "scapegoat" sort of, basically someone that she could always turn to and suspect if she didn't know who else to target. And of course, like I said would happen, Z turned out to be a citizen. Jenny voted for Z very very veryyyy quickly week one, which I always found disturbing.
6.) Staying out of the drama in chatrooms. Whenever people are discussing things, even some that involve her, she keeps her mouth shut.
etc etc etc I can go on and on

[Hambone]

Also, a possible link between her and alexei, because the vote was between Alexei and Z, and she was pushing for Z (as was Alexei at one point)

[Stephanie]

I am voting Jenny. For all of the same old reasons that Hambone has listed. I didn't like the Zeke exile and I suspect that Jenny's continued suspicions of him might have helped the exile. I find it very suspicious that Jenny has never taken a firm stance on anyone, never made a case on anyone, but continues to have these mild suspicions on whoever the likely bandwagon candidate might be. And I suspect encouraging the bandwagons in private, but never coming public with it.

[Jasmine]

Just want to point out it's interesting that hambone has yet to be online today but has the same reason as stephanie pointed out to me--that she has been on Zed for a long time. Just find that odd, maybe you guys have discussed it before tonight though..Who knows.

2.) Not revealing Nita's third party role

For this, I think she did it right..that she waited till the girl was imprisoned to out her. I think maybe if Nita was still in the game later on, she might have wanted to say something..but it was still early in the game, so I understand her keeping it to herself at that point.

Aside from that, I kind of understand. I've been very suspcious of her in the past as well. Nothing new has popped up, but she is an odd one. Not sure if I like a Jenny exile more then a Claude or Awohali one though. But I understand the reasoning.

[Hambone]

I have been making this case on Jenny since before the dinosaur era, Jasmine. Maybe if you bothered talking to me some more or commenting on my cases then you wouldn't have needed to say this!

You voted for Jenny last reason with no reason at all, same with Kiara. I'd like to know why please.

[Jasmine]

Well if you would read the "Away" thread you would know I was away for the last 5-6 days, so my votes for Jenny were based on the end of round 4.

And I wasn't trying to have a go at you, you asshole. I was just saying my thoughts on the whole thing of people voting Jenny.

[Awohali]

Jul 25, 2010 22:54:52 GMT -6 Jasmine said:

2.) Not revealing Nita's third party role

For this, I think she did it right..that she waited till the girl was imprisoned to out her. I think maybe if Nita was still in the game later on, she might have wanted to say something..but it was still early in the game, so I understand her keeping it to herself at that point.

Aside from that, I kind of understand. I've been very suspcious of her in the past as well. Nothing new has popped up, but she is an odd one. Not sure if I like a Jenny exile more then a Claude or Awohali one though. But I understand the reasoning.

One small problem:
If Jenny had been killed, there would have been no one else to alert the Town that Nita was a 3rd party. I hardly see how risking the secret dying with her was playing it "right". If anything, she should have told one or two others.

And also, I still see absolutely no benefit whatsoever for not outing Nita. She could have scum hunted, certainly, but she could just as easily pretend to and not really care either way. 3rd party has no allegiance to the Town and trusting them is crazy.