this has been bugging me
Aug 15, 2010 21:24:23 GMT -6
Post by Kiara on Aug 15, 2010 21:24:23 GMT -6
i noticed this awhile ago, but havent really pursued it until now. with lawrence flipping spy i definitely think its relevant, and seeing as im almost certain im going to be mislynced tomorrow, i figure it needs to be addressed before i dont have to choice to say anything and it gets overlooked
exile 1 - republicans
dane: stephanie, alexei
exile 2 - republicans
savannah: stephanie, dane
exile 3 - republican nomination
stephanie: lawrence, dane
lawrence: stephanie
exile 3 - republicans' decision
themba: isaac, dane
magalie: stephanie, lawrence
exile 4 - nominations (theoretical)
stephanie: lawrence, dane, isaac
lawrence: stephanie
exile 7 - nominations
dane: lawrence
lawrence: dane
the things that stand out most to me are
one final thing that needs to be answered is this: why is chance still alive? i saw just cause in the choices of broderick and claude before him, but why owen? he was slowly losing his credibility and could potentially have been exiled. chance is a confirmed citizen! my theory is this: the h&h group now at the time was down to owen, chance, mary, and me. everyone seems fairly certain that a spy is in there somewhere. it isnt chance, and with owen gone its down to me and mary. mary doesnt seem to be a strong suspect, so it makes me the prime target and an easy lynch. but what about stephanie? she was not part of the group, but she wasnt completely ignorant either. what if she was able to figure it out and thats where everything fell to hell? i dont think anyone has really considered that to be much of an option at this point.
exile 1 - republicans
dane: stephanie, alexei
exile 2 - republicans
savannah: stephanie, dane
exile 3 - republican nomination
stephanie: lawrence, dane
lawrence: stephanie
exile 3 - republicans' decision
themba: isaac, dane
magalie: stephanie, lawrence
exile 4 - nominations (theoretical)
stephanie: lawrence, dane, isaac
lawrence: stephanie
exile 7 - nominations
dane: lawrence
lawrence: dane
the things that stand out most to me are
- steph and larrys crossvoting in two consecutive rounds, it bothers me. both reasoning ep3 seemed very flimsy to me. strong enough to where people wouldnt find it suspect but weak enough to not persuade anyone else to jump on the wagon.
- steph being nominated in ep4. its wifom-tastic, i know, but im of the opinion that isaac voted steph to put her in the running. everyone knew it was a two horse race between jenny and isaac. steph, claude, and rondak were in no real danger. knowing now that claude was a cit, i think isaac may have spared the cits (and it pains me to consider rondak a cit here) and put spy stephanie in the hopes it might make her look more cit-ish
- someone is going to have to help me with this, because im cant remember who told me this, and im having a hard time finding it. but someone told me earlier on that alexei said that he though zed and dane were both citz and wouldnt be voting them. but in the end he did in fact vote dane. this bothers me for the simple fact that if he was going to try and save himself and break his word, why not vote for zed. can anyone confirm or refute any of this?
- i think the savannah wagon ep2 was a great place to wagon for spies. in fact, all of dane, steph, and rondak voted her. everyone else who did not are dead non-spies with the expections of me (and i know im a cit) and hambone (and i think hes a cit)
- there was a lot of talk that magalie was bussed by fellow spies ep3 knowing she was in no real danger. out of the 7 votes she received, 5 are dead citz, 1 in chance, and 1 is cinnamyn. what always bothered me more were the people who didnt vote themba in the revote. other than themba herself, it was on steph and lawrence. its a triple-whammy: they get cit points for not noming themba in the firstplace, they get cit points for not jumping on the cit exile wagon, and they get cit points when magalie flips a spy. had stephanie been a dem at any time, i could maybe see the vote. but i find it hard pressed to be willing to exile someone you havent had any interaction with unless you 100% know the other one is a cit.
one final thing that needs to be answered is this: why is chance still alive? i saw just cause in the choices of broderick and claude before him, but why owen? he was slowly losing his credibility and could potentially have been exiled. chance is a confirmed citizen! my theory is this: the h&h group now at the time was down to owen, chance, mary, and me. everyone seems fairly certain that a spy is in there somewhere. it isnt chance, and with owen gone its down to me and mary. mary doesnt seem to be a strong suspect, so it makes me the prime target and an easy lynch. but what about stephanie? she was not part of the group, but she wasnt completely ignorant either. what if she was able to figure it out and thats where everything fell to hell? i dont think anyone has really considered that to be much of an option at this point.
