|
Post by tonisha on Jul 16, 2010 19:28:35 GMT -6
Posting group chat transcripts is very useful for those people who miss them. However your contributions to catching spies, . Your method of hunting for citizens rather than spies is ineffectual as you don't try to sway voters away from those you think are citizens. The likelihood of you being a spy is much more than simply a lazy citizen. Attempting to save those you think are citizens would help you, if you don't want to hunt for spies.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 16, 2010 20:38:16 GMT -6
I wasn't sure what to think of you at first, and at times, actually found you to be a bit fake. After talking to you more, I don't think you're fake at all, and that you are actually legitimately playing and acting how you normally would.
I still wish you would open up more. You're great at providing information, when things happened, what happened, who said what, etc. However, that's where the issue lies -- you state facts much more than you state opinions. When you do state you're opinions, a lot of the time they're on the fence. I understand being unsure and indecisive, but you also often need to take a stance on things, otherwise you'll be extremely hard to read. If you are town, the harder you are to read, the more likely you are to be mislynched at some point.
I've recently seen a bit more personality from you and I've really enjoyed it. Keep going with that and I think others that haven't warmed up to you yet will.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 16, 2010 21:01:57 GMT -6
Dear Jenny, Eventually, being a double agent is going to get you killed. Probably by exile. When you lurk in chat rooms all day every day gathering information, eventually people will start asking questions when you don't spot anything but citizens like Callahan and defend them. You might want to have a roleclaim ready, and one that doesn't involve lying about your role or giving gifts to Spies. Also, never be the last remaining member of an apparent Citizen alliance. It gets you exiled every time. Good Luck, Iris
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 16, 2010 21:11:00 GMT -6
In one way you have provided plenty of evidence, you bring enlightenment to us with every secret you unveil. But if I were to say you could improve in a crucial aspect, it would be the way you use your knowledge. Knowing Savannah’s role after it is far too late to save her? Not really quite as helpful as going out there and putting up a counter case in the first place. The evidence you use always has a time and place, if you are a citizen and this evidence can help our cause this time is usually ASAP. Don’t worry so much about the info falling into the wrong hands; if you share with everyone there is nothing the spies can do to stop it.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 17, 2010 14:17:54 GMT -6
I think you need to be a bit more proactive. You've shown you're adept at Mafia and at the very least, a veteran to Spies. Why are you so unproductive? I'm new and have posted at least a case on someone. Please start telling people who you believe the Spies are rather than who they aren't.
Inviting people to the chats and posting the chat logs is great, but it's not really productive in the big scheme of catching Spies if you don't do anything with the logs you claim to scour over. One thing I like about you, though, is that you stay civil, despite being under fire from illogical or unruly people. I appreciate that. Being tunneled by someone is a frustrating process, I know, and I can only imagine how having Hambone on your case 24/7 makes you feel. So, thanks for the restraint.
I'd also request that you think of something else to start conversations with than "So what are you thinking? "
I hope this helps!
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 17, 2010 14:18:26 GMT -6
Jenny, you're doing a horrible job as a spy. To do better, what you have to do is next time, admit to not helping the third party people. Also, you shouldn't publicly reveal a citizens role when he is not in danger because that will only make you look very bad, and you will get caught very quickly. You should start to make cases on other people and voice your opinions rather than blindly following other people's cases.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 17, 2010 14:19:09 GMT -6
Citizen reads are great. They really are. Take the step beyond that though. Look at the people who are not obvious citizens and try and figure out which one of them looks the most awkward, say why that is, and get into the game. You have basically just touched on Zek and Magalie this entire game, both with decent points. Do that more often though. Love you for posting all the chats though.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 18, 2010 11:01:13 GMT -6
hey dare
jeny u rly ned 2 formalate n upiniun of ur own u c ur rly like der 2 plees al da ppl n its knda idk suppicus
so ma advis 2 u is 2 fukn not be so indersisiv n shit lol jus let lose n say wut ur rly thinkin n shit
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 18, 2010 11:01:39 GMT -6
Hiiiii! Jenny! Hiiiii! I love your enthusiasm, and I love your nicknames. Don't let anyone else tell you they're annoying - they make me feel good about myself, at least. But honey, you can post all the vote counts and group chats you want and it ain't gonna let me know the least little bit about who you suspect! You say so much to so many people, now why is it I can't figure that little thing out? But you're playing this game fine, babe, don't let no one tell you different.
|
|
|
Post by tonisha on Jul 18, 2010 11:01:58 GMT -6
Jeeennyyy! Maybe if you would spend less time pretending to be Spies7Juliaaa and more time, um, idk, hunting for Spies, you would look less bad? I'm not trying to be meean here But yeah, you haven't hunted for Spies at all and it's by your own admission, and that doesn't really make sense, like this one time I was swimming at a pool and this guy, that looked reeallyyy creeeeeeepy, was trying to tell me about his Firebird that he owned and I was like "Um yeah, I don't really care about it that much" because he was talking about the engine and all this stuff I didn't understand, but anyways, the point was that he was talking about stuff that didn't matter to me, and you do that to everyone by aaalways bringing up past games as if they're a part of this game! I mean yeah it's good to know about the past games but you shouldn't be mentioning it alllll the tiiime! And you should probably come up with a more original character, because what you're doing has all been done, just like that Bare Naked Ladies song, teehee!
So if you wanna get better, try actually hunting for Spies and not Citizens because that's not really the best idea and it will get you in trouble and yeah, it looks bad. My friend Michelle just said that she thinks your black dress is cute but that you don't deserve to wear it if you don't hunt for Spies! Actually she didn't say that last part because she thinks Spies is silly, so I added it in, teehee! So yeah, actually look for Spies sometimes. Posting chats isn't enough contribution, girl.
|
|
Kiara
Kiara
little one
Posts: 76
|
Post by Kiara on Jul 24, 2010 17:50:19 GMT -6
Posting group chat transcripts is very useful for those people who miss them. However your contributions to catching spies, . Your method of hunting for citizens rather than spies is ineffectual as you don't try to sway voters away from those you think are citizens. The likelihood of you being a spy is much more than simply a lazy citizen. Attempting to save those you think are citizens would help you, if you don't want to hunt for spies. ive been saying this since i entered that game. jennys contributions have been mostly limited to the posting of the group chats. it reaks of someone trying to look helpful without actually being helpful! Jenny, you're doing a horrible job as a spy. To do better, what you have to do is next time, admit to not helping the third party people. Also, you shouldn't publicly reveal a citizens role when he is not in danger because that will only make you look very bad, and you will get caught very quickly. You should start to make cases on other people and voice your opinions rather than blindly following other people's cases. i still dont say knowing about nita role is all that damning! in fact i actually think it was pretty stupid of the spies to exile her if jenny is a spy. they had her in an easily manipulatable position. as for claiming allans role, i still hold by the fact that he very well could have gone that episode had she not. and had she not it would have looked scummy to nita because she knew that jenny knew. regardless of alignment i think her claiming was the right thing.
|
|