|
|
Post by Mary on Jul 1, 2010 11:30:16 GMT -6
This first post is a placeholder. It will eventually be replaced with our summary case and devil's advocate points about Magalie should she be our nominee.
Please post your arguments and counterarguments below and over the course of the day we can come up with a concise brief for the Republicans to read in the short time they have for their final votes at Exile tonight.
|
|
|
|
Post by Awohali on Jul 1, 2010 11:39:57 GMT -6
I will be as brief as possible:
1. Magalie has not been very active. She is rarely online and does not accomplish much when she is on.
2. Magalie's reasoning for voting suspicions are poor.
A. She voted Gertrude after stating that she was probably an honest Cit, later admitting that she actually suspected her and said that only to get people to leave her alone, but later admitting that she actually felt like she was voting for a Cit under fire in Gertrude.
B. She gave what sounded like a purely copied/parroted suspicion of Stephanie, then later claimed that she did not actually say that she suspected her. Upon being shown the quote, she amended her claim to "i didnt mean it like that".
3. She was detrimental to our team during the final challenge. For the one before the final challenge, she logged on and then said she had to reboot before we started. Her reboot took two hours, and she stuck by that when she got back on.
During the final challenge, she stayed on and got her assignment of flags, and then said or did nothing for several minutes before saying that she had to go, and logged offline. By taking an assignment of 5 flags, which were some of the final flags that we identified, and not actually looking for them, she hurt our team. Intentional or not, it was very disheartening.
4. She has not, to my knowledge, asked many questions or done any Spy hunting. If she can post evidence of this here, then that is great, but I can not recall it existing.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mary on Jul 1, 2010 11:52:07 GMT -6
I'll add the things I have that aren't duplicates of Awohali's.
She said "that's gettin me nowhere" about her Gertrude suspicions, which is an odd choice of words.
She suspected Nita for what appeared to be basically OMGUS, and then denied suspecting her the next day until shown the chat log.
She said she suspected Lilith in a post and later dropped it.
Her vote for Margot appeared to be purely that Margot was "under the radar".
She seems to look for excuses to leave chats.
Her Claude suspicions last night were also weak.
|
|
Cory
Cory
Hot Because He's Fly
Posts: 127
|
Post by Cory on Jul 1, 2010 12:12:49 GMT -6
She avoided taking a definite stance on the three people she listed under her exile 2 vote possibilities, and listed vague peculiarities about them.
|
|
