Jazzy Is Suspecting Claude
Jul 23, 2010 15:41:46 GMT -6
Post by Jasmine on Jul 23, 2010 15:41:46 GMT -6
Seriously, after this latest 'fake messenger' fiasco, there is no way that you can think that Magalie is a Spy.
You are effectively arguing that Magalie A)faked recieving a fake message from a Spy role, telling her that Tina is the Doctor(nevermind that this would mean that the person whom creates this message just didn't bother to use it on the day that Magalie would have received it), in order to knowingly(and falsely) present herself as a completely petty and spiteful person.
It's ridiculous and virtually impossible. Magalie DEFINTELY did not come up with it on her own, and I am not convinced that someone would go along with their spy teammates promoting such a convoluted plan, especially when it has a good result of getting modkilled anyway.
The alternative, which is that Magalie legitimately received the message in question and was gullible enough to believe it, and spiteful enough to try to 'take the town down with her', is infinitely more believable.
Sam should act against Magalie. The town should not. The likelihood of her being a Spy is miniscule.
If she gets lynched, everyone involved, especially those on the Senate, will become Suspects in my eyes. If she gets lynched and Chance ever actually gets lynched like he deserves and flips Spy, then I will never, ever let anyone that votes Magalie today live it down. Choose your action carefully.
Lol. I love that you refer to her as 'clearly anti-town' now. Yesterday, you were adamant about having no read on her but just wanting to lynch her for lurking.
Now, it is undeniable that she acted against the best interests of the town with her 'reveal' yesterday. It is also all but undeniable that she is still a citizen, despite having done so. The notion that she pretend to receive a message that was never actually sent is just complete nonsense. That would mean that whichever Spy sends messages chose not to send one that day, just to be able to run this 'gambit' later. It would mean that the Spies gave Magalie a vote while simultaneously assuming that she was going to get lynched(meaning that they wasted their chance to give someone a vote).
The sum of this simply does not add up to magalie being a Spy. I am speaking against her lynch because, as I have said all along, sometimes you have to see past the surface level of things and actually do some analysis. So, did Magalie commit an anti-town act here? Yes, she absolutely did. However, the details of said anti-town act prove that she is town, and is not a viable lynch candidate. It is easy enough for Sam to simply replace her. Lynching her is simply bad.
^ Both from the Exile 5(Nominations) Thread. Does this not shout"spy" to anyone else? On top of that, his role...what have you been using it on recently, Claude? Is this public knowledge, or? I might have just missed where you have been telling us though. But please maybe sum it up, I haven't been around. But anyone else suspect him?? Anything else to look at? Just getting back and those posts of him defending Magalie make me really question him. We need to settle the Chance vs Claude thing eventually. Most likely leading in one being a spy. And in that, I think it's Claude at the moment.
Would love some Claude thoughts on what has been going on since I left about five days ago with him. Anything suspect...or?
You are effectively arguing that Magalie A)faked recieving a fake message from a Spy role, telling her that Tina is the Doctor(nevermind that this would mean that the person whom creates this message just didn't bother to use it on the day that Magalie would have received it), in order to knowingly(and falsely) present herself as a completely petty and spiteful person.
It's ridiculous and virtually impossible. Magalie DEFINTELY did not come up with it on her own, and I am not convinced that someone would go along with their spy teammates promoting such a convoluted plan, especially when it has a good result of getting modkilled anyway.
The alternative, which is that Magalie legitimately received the message in question and was gullible enough to believe it, and spiteful enough to try to 'take the town down with her', is infinitely more believable.
Sam should act against Magalie. The town should not. The likelihood of her being a Spy is miniscule.
If she gets lynched, everyone involved, especially those on the Senate, will become Suspects in my eyes. If she gets lynched and Chance ever actually gets lynched like he deserves and flips Spy, then I will never, ever let anyone that votes Magalie today live it down. Choose your action carefully.
Lol. I love that you refer to her as 'clearly anti-town' now. Yesterday, you were adamant about having no read on her but just wanting to lynch her for lurking.
Now, it is undeniable that she acted against the best interests of the town with her 'reveal' yesterday. It is also all but undeniable that she is still a citizen, despite having done so. The notion that she pretend to receive a message that was never actually sent is just complete nonsense. That would mean that whichever Spy sends messages chose not to send one that day, just to be able to run this 'gambit' later. It would mean that the Spies gave Magalie a vote while simultaneously assuming that she was going to get lynched(meaning that they wasted their chance to give someone a vote).
The sum of this simply does not add up to magalie being a Spy. I am speaking against her lynch because, as I have said all along, sometimes you have to see past the surface level of things and actually do some analysis. So, did Magalie commit an anti-town act here? Yes, she absolutely did. However, the details of said anti-town act prove that she is town, and is not a viable lynch candidate. It is easy enough for Sam to simply replace her. Lynching her is simply bad.
^ Both from the Exile 5(Nominations) Thread. Does this not shout"spy" to anyone else? On top of that, his role...what have you been using it on recently, Claude? Is this public knowledge, or? I might have just missed where you have been telling us though. But please maybe sum it up, I haven't been around. But anyone else suspect him?? Anything else to look at? Just getting back and those posts of him defending Magalie make me really question him. We need to settle the Chance vs Claude thing eventually. Most likely leading in one being a spy. And in that, I think it's Claude at the moment.
Would love some Claude thoughts on what has been going on since I left about five days ago with him. Anything suspect...or?
HELP ME FELLOW CITIZENS. HELP JAZZY OUT!!